| editorial
The LUDA e-newsletter is a free
electronic document, edited by the LUDA research team from the Leibniz
Institute of Ecological and Regional Development in Dresden (Germany).
The e-newsletter is distributed every three months, providing project
updates, information on current affairs and details of other
interesting issues.
The 7th issue of the newsletter is
dedicated to the partner city Lisbon. In our series "Cities Stories"
the Lisbon Team presents different aspects of the case study area Ameixoeira /
Galinheiras, like the uses of the open spaces, problems of
migration and illegal buildings as well as social, historical and
economic aspects of revitalisation. However the Lisbon Team offered a
wide overview now the Lisbon "Cities Stories" is not finished; in the
forthcoming newsletter issues other aspects of the case study area will
be further discussed.
Julie Gannon and Gillian O'Brien from DIT Dublin in the essay calls for
a better link between the property-led regeneration and social renewal
explaining it on the example of the current policy approaches towards
urban regeneration in Ireland.
We wish you a nice lecture!
The IOER LUDA Team
|
|
| top |
|
highlights
3rd LUDA Conference: "Sharing
Experiences"
The next project conference "Sharing
Experiences - Developing Strategies for Large Urban Distressed Areas"
will take place from 2nd to 3rd December 2004 in Salzburg. The aim of
the conference is to provide a platform for the direct involvement of
the Reference Cities into the project, to enhance the networking
activities within the project consortium and to broader transfer of the
project results.
The presentations and discussions about the cities experience will
follow in three groups: 1. Specific Experience in Environmental Quality
and Urban Structure Aspects, 2. Specific Experiences in Human/Social
Development and Economic Development aspects, 3. Specific Experiences
in Community Capacity/Governance and image aspects. The presented
examples and results of the discussions will be included in the LUDA
Compendium. About the progress we will inform you in the next issue of
the newsletter.
A LUDA declaration on requirements for the new urban policies will be
discussed and adopted in Salzburg. The declaration includes the
requirements on the EU policy for the future handling of increasing
social and spatial polarisation in the cities, leading to the emergence
of large urban distressed areas. The declaration refers to the
definition of the research on the one hand and to the revitalisation
programmes of the large distressed areas on the other.
|
|
|
Good practice asked
Sharing experiences goes beyond the
conference. The LUDA project is searching for experiences and on the
project website under http://www.luda-project.net/netw01.html
the following inquiry is posted:
How the inhabitants of LUDA
zones can be led to acceptance of changes in their environment and how
to increase their participation in the process?
The aim of this inquiry is to collect the good practice examples. There
are already some answers from our Partner Cities: Edinburgh,
Valenciennes, Florence and Lisbon. We want to ask you to share with us
your experiences!
|
|
Actions in the case study Area
Dresden
The pilot projects of the partner city
Dresden aim at improving the image of the Weißeritz area. This
area suffers from low or not existing land use pressure of the
private sector, low image, wasteland, empty houses and not appropriate
land uses, contamination of the ground as well as a flood hazard. In
order to enhance the image building the art project Licht+Spiele
(Light and Plays) was carried out by LUMOPOL (www.lumopol.de) and supported by the
municipality of Dresden.
During a week in September 2004, 12 art
objects with lightning effects were exhibited around, in and over the
river Weißeritz, the backbone of the area
(http://www.lumopol.de/lichtspiele/uebersicht.html). The exhibition was
part of a public relations campaign that involved panels’ discussions
about the relationship between “lighting art” and urban development.
This camp aign aimed at attracting the inhabitants’ attention and as
symbols for the identification potential.
For the first time many persons were confronted with the peculiarities
of the Weißeritz area and an encouraging perception of the areas
characteristics could be identified.
During this week the new proposal for the green corridor through the
Weißeritz area has been also publicly presented.
More about the actions in the city of Dresden will be presented in the
next issue of the newsletter which will be dedicated to the city of
Dresden.
|
|
|
Vincent Fravel
paid a visit to Bratislava - Raca
During the workshop in Lisbon, there was
an informal
discussion between Mr Vincent Farvel - scientific officer of the
European
Commission and Mrs Petríková and Mr Furdík of
Bratislava-Raca about particularities and differences of case studies
in the Partner Cities. During the discussion Mr. Farwell was invited to
visit Bratislava.
Mr Favrel paid a visit on the 02.09.2004
to Bratislava,
where the mayor, Mr P. Bielik welcomed him. The visit included a site
visit to the case study area of Raca. Mr. Bielik introduced the city to
the guests supported by aerial maps of the Bratislava- Raca.
Our concrete cognition of the LUDA case
study in
Bratislava began from the intersection of the north-west railway line,
through areas of Pri Šajbách, Dopravná ulica-Rendez. The
site visit continued with depot, agricultural used areas and the second
part of Luda Žabí Majer. During the journey there were been
presented the ongoing projects and discussed specific problems of
whole area and its single parts, possible solutions and the
perspectives.
There were some topics emerged from the
discussion:
- The process of developing a master
plan and territorial progress is made between vision, concepts and
reality.
- Main problem of LUDA in
Bratislava-Raca is its spatial isolation and the insufficient
facilities in the area and in its neighbourhoods.
- Solving problems of LUDA is a
long-term process and its successful realisation requires
systematically approach with participation of inhabitants,
stakeholders, municipality and experts.
- In addiction to the long-term
goals is necessary to solve day-to-day problems in the area.
Bratislava Team
|
|
Distressed areas and "The Young Forum" 2004 in Dresden
The in 1946 founded Academy for Spatial
Research and Planning (ARL) is a research institute active in
fundamental and applied spatial research. The ARL is a member of the
scientific association Leibniz (WGL).
The Academy is an interdisciplinary network. The task of this network
is to bring together competences within the spatial sciences. So the
self-conception of ARL is to be a forum to promote co-operation both
between theory and practice as well as on the spatial scale among the
regions.
Another important aim is to promote young scientist in spatial planning
and research. That's why the ARL founded 1998 the network "Junges
Forum". Its principal function is to facilitate the contact between the
generations of scientists as well as the exchange of knowledge and
experience within the spatial sciences. The Forum takes place once a
year at changing locations. The venue in 2004 was the Leibniz Institute
of Ecological and Regional Development in Dresden (IÖR). Over 50
practitioners, researchers as well as students discussed about the
characteristics and impacts of distressed areas on urban or regional
level as well as the possibilities of planers to deal with such areas.
Special interest of the last meeting was to find answers for the
following questions with regard to urban distressed areas:
- How is the impact of
growing or shrinking process of the population?
- What are the challenges for
planning practitioners and researchers?
- What restrictions do influence
the process of restructuring?
- How do change the bad image of
such areas by restructuring activities?
These thematic cores were discussed and concretised in
three working groups. Furthermore reflections to distressed areas were
given through the presentations and an excursion in the LUDA
"Weißeritz" in Dresden.
The results and contributions of the participants of this forum will be
published as working material in 2005 by the ARL.
The next Young Forum will take place from 1st to 3rd of June 2005 in
Gelsenkirchen. The subject of this meeting will be the situations and
perspectives of agglomerations development.
Leander
Küttner (IOER)
|
|
| top |
|
| worth
knowing
The Greencluster Project
The Greencluster Project from the
Initiative "City-of-Tomorrow" of the EU is clustering five research
projects on green space in urban areas. Five ongoing EU funded research
projects are addressing, from different perspectives, the function of
green space in the urban environment. Rather than presenting the
results of these individual projects in a fragmented way, the projects
have come together to present their findings in a co-ordinated manner
in order to enhance their impact.
The projects of the Greencluster, address the various functional values
of green space. These functions include their contribution to social,
economic and environmental well being of the city. As the projects
range in their approaches from fundamental to applied and from highly
technical to primarily participatory and communicative, there is an
academic challenge in demonstrating how the projects can supplement
each other and together be more than the sum of the constituent parts.
To read more about the project please
look under: www.greencluster.org
|
|
|
The conference on urban renewal in
Warsaw
An international conference, titled:
"Urban Renewal Of Housing, Social And Economic Substance - Creation Of
Social, Cultural, And Tourist Projects Within The Degraded Urban And
Post-Industrial Areas", was held in Warsaw on 10th and 11th September
2004 under the patronage of the Mayor of the Capital City of Warsaw and
the President of EUROCITIES (the Network of Major European Cities).
The aim of the conference was to share experiences about the renewal of
degraded urban areas, with reference to examples of urban renewal
projects and the possibility of financing such projects from EU funds.
The example discussed was the Old Praga District in Warsaw.
Over the two days, attendees were invited to listen to 65 short
lectures and were divided into 6 working groups. The atmosphere of the
renovated "Fabryka Trzciny" building, featuring creatively designed
interiors, encouraged intense discussion amongst participants.
|
|
Case study Praga
The first attempts to revitalise Warsaw
began in the early 1990s. However, there were many formal problems
including a lack of legal regulations and lack of appropriate
instruments. Now, with access to structural funds from the EU, urban
renewal is possible. The Praga district, in inner city Warsaw, is one
of the revitalisation areas. The project is managed by the
"Holding-Wars S.A" - the Warsaw Development Company.
Residents see Warsaw as divided into 2 parts: the better one on the
left bank of the Vistula, and the bad one on the right - the Praga
district. Praga has never been fully integrated into the main body of
the city. It was not destroyed during the World War II and is,
therefore, very valuable for Warsaw, which was destroyed to a great
extent. But Praga became an industrial district and the hinterland of
Warsaw. It was also fortunate to escape the post-war "reconstruction"
and redevelopment, concentrated in the city centre
|
|
|
This district now suffers social
deprivation, poverty, and a poor image (small-and larger scale
criminality, mafia elements, acts of aggression) on the one hand yet,
on the other hand, is centrally located with many historical and
cultural buildings, including unique historical residential substance.
A significant proportion of the pre-1939 housing stock has remained to
the present day, alongside most of the factories. Public properties
were often under- or badly-used and are in bad technical condition,
requiring renovation. The high density of residential accommodation is
problematic: in order to revitalise and improve living standards, some
displacement will be necessary.
Renovation is already underway in Praga. The district is becoming
fashionable, on account of its unique ambience, with artists
establishing workshops and entrepreneurs converting factories into
cultural centres, other institutions and private businesses.
Key-notes
Despite the division of the attendees
into working groups, some common aspects of revitalisation can be noted
from this conference.
Social aspects:
Revitalisation is about conceptualising the city as a bridge between
the past and the present, and in a constant state of flux.
Revitalisation serves the residents rather than the tourists, as
tourists are often looking for authenticity.
Urban renewal and development must take into consideration the social
environment and the nature of the city. During the revitalisation
process, residents cannot be forgotten as the addressees of the
actions. Therefore, concentrating on city neighbourhoods and their
characteristics and developing more public spaces will be most
beneficial to the local population in conjunction with
interdisciplinary approaches to the revitalisation plans, and clear
competency descriptions of the NGOs active locally. The renovation and
reuse of vacant buildings can create new working environments for local
people. Conserving historical valuable buildings is an important factor
in developing the local identity and improving area's image.
Identifying the social milieus makes it possible to integrate local
people into the revitalisation process and make use of the local
community's potential. There is also a need to improve the
infrastructure (transport services, street lighting etc) and potential
for tourism. Through the constant monitoring of the projects, changes
and developments can be evaluated and modified, if necessary.
Financing and legal regulations:
Public-private partnerships are growing in popularity across Europe, in
terms of regeneration projects, leading to improved co-ordination and
financial flexibility. These partnerships introduce new sources of
finance, new skills and technological experience, new management and
organizational structures and fewer public sector risks. However, the
disadvantages of public-private partnerships include higher public
risks, complex, detailed and costly contracts, extended concessions,
less flexibility and the risks associated with private capital.
There is a need for further relevant legislation in Poland. New
revitalisation law should encompass the new and complex forms of
financing and regulations relating to Public-Private Partnerships. The
existing tools for revitalisation are not sufficient and should also be
revised. There is also a need for regulations towards easy accessible
credits for the revitalisation. The regulations dealing with the
revitalisation process have to offer flexibility and not restrict the
stakeholders and operators. Without regulations in these areas,
structural funds in Poland cannot be fully absorbed in order to address
the complex programmes tackling social, economic and spatial problems.
Physical aspects:
The revitalisation projects have to integrate social, economic,
physical and promotional aspects. The sole concentration on physical
revitalization results only in the displacement of poorer residents,
shunting social problems into other areas of the city. An urban
renaissance project should be based on civic principles and contribute
to the construction of a city where residents can live in a pleasant
environment.
The revitalisation of a city can lead to beneficial competition with
other cities through physical renewal and, above all, offer potential
for new forms of social and economic activities.
Pilot projects, in these large distressed areas, are very important as
they can act as catalysts in the revitalisation process. Very often,
these early projects relate to culture as a means of improving the
site's image and attracting tourists and investors. There are some key
points to be considered in the revitalisation process, such as: the
size of the investments, location, transport infrastructure and the
appropriate uses.
The industrial heritage of Warsaw is very attractive both educationally
and in terms of tourism. However, these are only exploited to a small
extent. The knowledge about the industrial buildings should be involved
in developing the identity of the residents; involved into the school
education this knowledge can assist the development of the creativity,
innovation and initiative of the residents.
Exchange of experiences
The exchange of experiences and accumulated knowledge amongst the
cities is an important tool in the revitalisation processes. The
Community Initiative Programme, URBACT, facilitates networking between
cities from all the Member States. The website http://www.urbact.org
constitutes the main platform of exchange between cities, the
presentation of analytical summaries of examples in practice, the
process of capitalisation and the principal tool of dissemination.
Patrycja Bielawska -
Roepke (IOER)
language revision Fiona H. Campbell
pictures with a kind permission of the information service Praga
Polnoc, www.praga-pn.waw.pl
Call for Applications:
Course on Planning and Financing Cities in Transition: The Strategic
Approach
The course presents an integrated
approach to meet urban challenges. It shows how urban development and
financing strategies can and should be integrated in the overall urban
strategy and its implementation. It uses exercises and it is build on
various cases studies from the region and beyond to illustrate the
concepts presented.
The course will take place in Budapest in two 5-day blocks: January
24-28, and March 7-11, 2005. The language of the course is English.
The course has six modules: introduction
on cities and globalization, strategic approach, public choices in
financing and organization of services urban challenges, specific
services, integration of strategies and activities. During the course,
a variety of teaching techniques will be used: lectures, case studies
presentations and discussion, in-class exercises, professional
city-tour on the Budapest development sites and meeting with
professionals working on the filed.
The course is offered to practitioners,
local and central government officials and decision-makers,
policy-makers and policy advisors, think-tank experts from the South
East European countries of: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria,
Croatia, Macedonia, Moldova, Romania, Serbia and Montenegro, and
Turkey. The organizers will pay tuition, accommodation, meals and
health insurance for selected applicants. Participants are expected to
pay their travel costs, and visa-related costs.
Applicants are encouraged to submit with
their application a two-page proposal for a case study that they know
from their practice. The case study can be on any topic belonging to
the six course modules. The faculty will select the best three proposed
case studies, and selected applicants will be offered travel-cost
waivers if they submit fully developed case studies by January 10, 2005.
Final deadline for applications is
November 29, 2004.
for more information and application
forms please look under: http://lgi.osi.hu/documents.php?id=166
|
|
|
|
|
essay
Reforming Urban Renewal
Policies: the Role of Corporate Social Responsibility?
Urban regeneration is a challenge that
has increasingly dominated Irish Government policy agendas, and is one
that justifiably requires attention. This is particularly the case in
Dublin, where managing urban regeneration is a relatively recent
endeavour in comparison with most other European countries. Since the
enactment of the Urban Renewal Act, 1986, urban regeneration in Dublin
has been generally property-led, owing to a series of fashionable tax
incentive schemes introduced under the Act (DoE, 1986). Although these
schemes are recognised internationally as effective models to
facilitate urban regeneration, their success in Dublin has been limited
in terms of integrating the needs of the local communities of these
areas (MacLaran, 1993). It is suggested here that what is needed is a
more holistic approach to urban regeneration, an approach that no
longer turns a blind eye to the negative impacts that redevelopment can
have on local communities and the wider environment. Corporate Social
Responsibility (CSR), it is contended, is one such approach through
which this lack of integration can be tackled. By encouraging more
ethical and responsible behaviour on the part of the private sector,
CSR can help lead to the creation of more meaningful and trustworthy
partnerships between developers, public sector bodies and local
indigenous communities in order to make urban regeneration more
sustainable in the future.
Context
The city of Dublin has undergone a
series of rapid transformations in recent decades. Emerging from the
1980's as "probably the shabbiest, most derelict city in Europe" (Mc
Donald, 1985), today it embodies one of the most popular cities
internationally, having an almost "palpable 'buzz' about it" (McDonald,
2000), which is largely owing to the phenomenal economic growth
experienced during the 1990's; this growth, however, has not come
without its costs. Today, Dublin is faced with a multitude of
interrelated pressures and challenges, each of which must be resolved
through the implementation of specific and targeted responses (Roberts,
2000). Consequently, systems of urban governance in Ireland are
continually confronted with the need to address and overcome these
challenges, so that the urban entity as a whole can begin to function
effectively in an integrated and sustainable way; confronting the need
for sustainable urban regeneration is central to achieving this goal.
Urban Renewal Policies
in Dublin: Lessons Learned
There was no real concerted government
activity for the renewal of urban blackspots in Dublin until the
1980's, which saw the rise of a number of policy initiatives that
enabled the Irish government to tackle designated areas of urban decay
through fiscal measures. Legislation enacted during this period
provided the private sector with the incentive to invest in urban areas
that they would probably not have considered otherwise. These
initiatives were successful to the extent that they stimulated a major
physical renewal of the areas in question, as well as a boom in office
and residential development (Williams, 1999). This is particularly
evident, for example, by the decision to locate the international and
financial services centre (IFSC) in the Docklands area of Dublin, once
infamous for its derelict wastelands (www.ifsc.ie). Unfortunately,
there is evidence of 'dead weight', in that some of the projects that
enjoyed tax breaks under these schemes might have gone ahead anyway.
Furthermore, these schemes have contributed to current spiralling land
prices (KPMG, 1996) and the marginalisation of local communities
through the process of gentrification. Perhaps if private property-led
investors were influenced to evaluate the impact of their development
activities on the surrounding locality by means of tax-related
stipulations obliging companies to act in a socially responsible
manner, the problems evident today may have been avoided. Instead, what
we have witnessed is a failure to link property-led regeneration with
social renewal. There is a call, therefore, for reforming current
policy approaches towards urban regeneration in Ireland, and
particularly so in Dublin, where one third of the population resides.
Corporate Social
Responsibility: The Way Forward?
Sustainable urban regeneration can only
be realised if a long-term strategic framework for development is
adopted that ensures development occurs in accord with the principles
of sustainable development, encompassing both social responsibility and
ethical behaviour. Establishing meaningful partnerships between all
involved in the redevelopment of an area is central to this objective;
the role of the private sector cannot be underestimated in this regard.
Urban regeneration is by nature an interventionist activity that has
become increasingly a matter of public-private consensus. With this
growing trend towards Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) in urban
regeneration, it is clear that there is a need to ensure that business
acts responsibly and in concert with the local community of the area.
CSR is an important instrument that can ensure this goal is fulfilled:
that the private sector plays its part in rising to the challenges of
sustainable urban regeneration by integrating social, environmental and
economic considerations into its decision-making processes at all
levels during a regeneration project. In this way, trust would be built
up between the different interests of the project. For example,
applying CSR initiatives to a regeneration project would require the
developer to take into account the specified nature of the
disadvantaged area under scrutiny by investing in both the physical and
non-physical elements of the existent community.
Without doubt, the primary function of business is to create value by
producing goods and services that society needs. It is, however,
becoming more apparent that business can simultaneously make a
contribution to the needs and goals of society and the environment by
integrating CSR as part of its overall corporate strategy. The basic
concept of CSR is that business and society are closely interwoven,
rather than distinct entities. Igloo, for example, is a UK regeneration
partnership that invests in creating environmentally sustainable,
mixed-use, well-designed, urban neighbourhoods in regeneration areas on
the edge of 20 city centres. The partnership is committed to a policy
of 'socially responsible investment' to ensure that whilst achieving
acceptable financial returns, social and environmental benefits are
also delivered to the area. Put simply, Igloo believes that by adopting
this ethos, its investments will perform better because they will
contribute to the regeneration of the area and the indigenous community
as an entirety (www.igloo.uk.net). Recognising the interdependence
between business and society, it is argued, is vital if progress
towards sustainable urban regeneration is to be made.
Conclusion
Urban policy must be in line with the
pace and scale of urban change so that it can have a significant enough
influence over the form and functioning of cities in the 21st century,
and in particular their distressed areas, which will undoubtedly
represent areas of strategic importance in the future. Because cities
matter, and bear an overwhelming influence, not only on regional, but
national economic progress and development, urban policy must evolve to
reflect the changing assignment of responsibility for the effective
management of urban regeneration (Roberts, 2000). As Stegman noted "the
tragedy of the inner city affects everyone" and the overall performance
of a city bears consequences for the rest of the country. Corporate
social responsibility is vital in the plight to achieve sustainable,
civic and accountable systems of urban governance through which urban
regeneration can be realised more effectively. Owing to the fact that
urban regeneration is an activity which is likely to experience
considerable changes in its governing structures in the future, it is a
good time for business to take on board the guiding principles of CSR,
such as operating ethically and with integrity; sustaining the
environment for future generations; and becoming socially interactive
within the community. By embracing these principles of CSR, therefore,
both the private sector and the public domain can reap the benefits and
areas of urban distress are a prime example of a sector of society
where these benefits are clearly required.
References
Department of the Environment (1986)
Urban Renewal Act, The Stationery Office, Dublin.
KPMG, et al. (1996) Study on the Urban
Renewal Schemes, Department of the Environment, The Stationery Office,
Dublin.
MacLaran, A. (1993) Dublin: the Shaping
of a Capital, Belhaven Press, London and New York.
McDonald, F. (1985) The Destruction of
Dublin, Gill & Macmillan.
McDonald, F. (2000) The Construction of
Dublin, Gandon Editions.
Roberts, P. (2000) The Evolution,
Definition and Purpose of Urban Regeneration. In Roberts, P. and Sykes,
H. (eds.) (2000) Urban Regeneration: A Handbook.
Roberts, P. and Sykes, H. (eds.) (2000)
Urban Regeneration: A Handbook, SAGE Publications Ltd., London.
Julie Gannon, Gillian
O'Brien, The Futures Academy, Dublin Institute of Technology
|
|
|
|
Cities
stories
LISBON
The Lisbon case study area,
Ameixoeira/Galinheiras, has been considered part of Lisbon since 1852.
This area, with 185 ha and a population around 20 000 inhabitants, is
placed between four different boundaries: the main road going north out
of Lisbon; the territorial limit of the city which borders two other
municipalities; the Lisbon airport; and another important road,
currently under construction. It is a heterogeneous area that includes
a historical quarter, a number of residential buildings, illegal
buildings and, as a result, experiences serious social problems. The
area was chosen as the LUDA case study on account of its social
problems and the lack of urban planning.
The social problems mainly relate to the lack of facilities
(educational, social and health care) and also the evident social
exclusion, conflicts and increasing insecurities caused by the recent
concentration of minority ethnic populations (namely gypsies) now
living in the reallocation buildings.
The other problems are essentially
related to the poor quality of existing buildings, the illegal
properties and the absence of urban planning which has resulted in
other struggles, in terms of public spaces, roads and public transport.
In the historical quarter there are
specific problems concerning the old buildings which have patrimonial
value yet are deteriorating day-after-day, due to the lack of private
and public financing.
To solve these problems, the strategy
developed by the Lisbon LUDA team is thematic and all the programmes
will be developed towards the central theme of "music". With this
"Music Strategy", the area will also begin to play an important role in
the development of the city as a whole, given that music is a factor
linked to sophisticated activities, to innovation and to the
development of human beings. The existing project, on the development
of a new Music School in Ameixoeira, can be transformed into a
strategic project for the development of the whole area, largely
through promoting links between the school and excluded people and also
by developing a cluster of economic activities related to music.
This strategy implies greater participation from residents and
stakeholders. Starting by knowing their needs and wishes, capacities
and ideas, the implementation of the strategy will require the creation
of small groups to focus on specific problems and also the
establishment of neighbourhood groups.
In anticipation of achieving these aims,
the multidisciplinary LUDA Lisbon Team decided to write a city story
based around specific themes. The following series of articles
demonstrate that each member of the team is bearing in mind the
important steps in progressing toward improving the quality of life in
the Lisbon large urban distressed area.
|
|
Vegetablle gardens: bridging rural and urban spaces
Lisbon's peripheral landscape preserves
visible rural landmarks, legacies from Arabian and Roman occupation.
However, the convents, farms, old pedestrian roads, olive groves and
vegetable gardens which reflect both urban and rustic values and
contribute to a cultural and humanist expression of the city, are being
ignored by a chaotic urban expansion.
Located in the north fringe of Lisbon, the LUDA case study area
constitutes a vague testimony of this traditional landscape: the farms
of the Ameixoeira historical area, the old net of pedestrian roads that
ensured local circulation and other rural structures that remain
intact. Despite the tendency to depreciate and abandon these historical
legacies, rural values remain rooted in the local population through
the plantation of vegetable gardens.
In fact, intra-urban agriculture, a
micro-scale phenomenon in Lisbon as a whole, has a strong expression in
the LUDA case study area peripheral neighbourhoods, where a part of the
population finds its cultural roots through gardening. The free spaces,
fallow lands, yards, patios and flowerbeds are frequently used by this
population for the plantation of fruit and ornamental trees, mixed with
vegetable, aromatic and medicinal plants and, sometimes, with the
raising of small animals.
At present, urban agriculture constitutes a universal reality with
economic, social and ecological consequences.
Domestic vegetable gardens are a source
of increased income for less affluent families allowing an easy supply
of fresh provisions and the sale of traditional products such as
flowers and plants. However these spaces aren't just appealing to less
affluent citizens. All over Europe we can observe the development of a
new class of vegetable garden's users, from a different economic and
vocational background, who transform urban vegetable gardens into
landscaped garden spaces where the family will spend most of their free
time. In Portugal, this is not a significant phenomenon within the
urban space, but it has begun to impact upon some rural areas that are
often chosen by the urban population for weekend residences. As a form
of leisure activity where participants can enjoy close contact with
nature, gardening plays an important role in maintaining mental and
physical stability in those who practice it. Gardening can also work to
establish the dynamics of communitarian organization and solidarity,
and constitutes an interesting instrument in terms of addressing social
inclusion.
The contribution of these spaces to the
improvement of the urban environment is also important. Planting
vegetation on vacant land, whether it is wasteland or destined for real
estate development, will aid water circulation, help reduce soil
erosion, increase the permeability of the soil and work to combat
pollution. The benefits of the integration of urban vegetable gardens
in areas of the city where the rural heritage has been conserved as
with the Lisbon LUDA requires recognition and urgent attention in order
to promote their protection and avoid deterioration.
The importance of these spaces is
demonstrated in the Ameixoeira Valley Urban Park project integrated
into the Peripheral Park plan. Part of Lisbon's ecological structure,
the Peripheral Park has been developed along the northern stripe of the
council's border and is constituted by a continuous reticulated
structure, starting in Monsanto Park and finishing in Ameixoeira. The
Peripheral Park includes remarkable farms, historical quarters, old
pedestrian roads, cemeteries and industrial areas that are coherently
interconnected, aiming at the qualification of public spaces and a
higher living standards for residents. In the Ameixoeira Valley
strategy, the Peripheral Park will include vegetable garden areas that
will be allocated to the inhabitants of the Alto do Chapeleiro
neighbourhood, whilst also promoting the appropriation of the park by
its users.
An urban development can't, therefore, neglect its heritage and should
promote land uses that improve civic functioning, correspond to
citizens' needs and desires and perform a fundamental role in the
preservation of the collective memory.
Maria Almeida
|
|
|
History of a building: Quinta de Santo
Antonio
"Santo António" Estate is an old
property, both rustic and urban, situated on an old road in the
historical area of Ameixoeira, known as "Santo António" alley.
This magnificent house, consisting of two floors and a separate
construction used, in the past, as a Billiards Room; also includes a
beautiful terrace over the old stable, coach house garage and cellar;
3600 m2 of kitchen-gardens and 350 m2 of landscaped gardens.
The building dates from before the 17th Century when it belonged to Dr.
Luiz de Foios de Souza, a squire and politician from the Lisbon Senate,
who ordered the construction of a new chapel with the invocation of
"Santo António", in 1684.
In the 18th Century, after a number of
different inhabitants had imposed their personalities upon the estate,
the farm consisted of: the main residence, a store, a watering hole, a
well and landscaped garden, vineyards, a shed with its respective fence
and a Chapel.
During the 1800s, the property had
changed ownership and came to be the object of tenancy renewals, which
lasted until 1865. After this, the farm had new owners and inhabitants,
until a lawyer, a great figure of republican politics, acquired it in
1935 when it was in considerable poor condition, and proceeded to begin
its restoration.
In 1942, the residence returned to being
inhabited on a regular basis until 1972 when it was once more
abandoned, resulting from the death of its proprietors. However, this
time the period of decay was shorter and the house became a family
residence between 1979 and 1991; where definitively lost the affection
of those who had love it.
1991 marked a turning point in the
fortunes of the estate. The property was placed on the market and
attracted a purchaser who proposed to destroy the farm and promote new,
high-density buildings in order to give economical viability to the
land. The City Council of Lisbon intervened and prevented the
conclusion of the purchase, but the lack of concrete measures to
guarantee its preservation resulted in the complete destruction of the
estate. Transformed into a venue for illicit businesses, and the object
of vandalism, the farm was completely razed by a huge fire, which
spared only the tile façade.
Nowadays, from "Santo António"
Farm, remains signs from the Chapel in the cellar vestibule and the
window and door-openings from the main residence, among which is
possible to glimpse the colours of the sky. From the memory and the
glory of long ago, an estate can be reborn, inserted into a modern and
urban context, based upon the redevelopment of the building's shell.
This space could be destined for the establishment of a new facility,
or could be included in the "music as factor of local development"
philosophy, as a possible venue for the relocation of the " Music
Museum".
Tiago Spranger
History of a place:
Ameixoeira and Galinheiras
Until the mid-1950s, the case study area
consisted of summer residences for the Lisbon population, based in an
assemblage of farms, orchards, olive-groves, old roads and alleys, few
of which remain today. Due to the construction of the Portela Airport
and the consequent displacement of people from their homes on the
development site to the Galinheiras municipal quarter, a "construction
fever" began with the first land divisions in the "Casal de Nossa
Senhora da Saúde" and the new municipal quarter in Galinheiras.
This boom in construction lasted until the 1970s.
A sequence of national events, as the reduction of 1950/60 emigration
flows and a hastened decolonisation, that brought a large community
resident in the African colonies back to Portugal; resulted in a
growing search for inhabitation in Lisbon area. The real estate market
and cities planning were not prepared to this population boom and a
parallel market appeared, based on illegal housing buildings and
offering poor habitability conditions; originating neighbourhoods as
Galinheiras, Alto do Chapeleiro or Quinta da Torrinha.
At the same time, through Ameixoeira's
Valley, in a privileged part of Lisbon, illegal and degraded quarters
as "Quinta da Torrinha" and "Alto do Chapeleiro" grew up.
In 1999, a land division project presented by the Lisbon City council,
resulted in the recent construction of new rehousing buildings, known
as PER 1b, 2a, 3, 4, 5 and 6a; involving the Peripheral Park and
"Quinta da Torrinha".
The Ameixoeira's Valley development,
based on the construction of more reallocation complexes, became one of
the biggest problems within this area. Disappointment, violence,
discredit for the municipality and bad neighbourhood relationships,
generated a serious social conflict that is important to solve.
Recently, the Subway arrival, the last
chunk of "Eixo Norte/Sul" (the highway linking North and South Highways
out of Lisbon) construction and "Alto do Lumiar" master plan
implementation, as well as the construction of new buildings for the
free market, through the construction of the Europan winning project;
conferred to this area the necessary "energy" to implement its
development.
Tiago Spranger
|
|
|
A look over Galinheiras
Galinheiras is an important fragment of
a large urban distressed area which is located in a peripheral
territory, in the north of Lisbon. It covers an area of 46 ha, limited
SW by the Peripheral Park, NW by the military road, NE by the
administrative limit of the Lisbon municipality and SE by the future
urban road Eixo N-S (on an axis crossing the Lisbon metropolitan area).
Lisbon's master plan (PDM - Lisboa), approved in September 1994,
identifies Galinheiras as an operational unity of planning and the
space where it stands as destined for real estate development.
Galinheiras is a hybrid nucleus; the consequence of disordered,
uncontrolled and unplanned urban growth and a lengthy absence of urban
planning to coordinate the occupation of the area. It's a place known
for its depressed and illegal character, where a proportion of the
inhabitants are socially and economically deprived and live in poor
conditions. In physical terms, Galinheiras is a space which includes:
- Ancient rural structures,
such as agricultural farms;
- Recent urban rehousing structures
which are concentrated along the military road. The Galinheiras
municipal neighbourhood constructed this housing during the 1950s to
accommodate families who lost their homes as a consequence of the
airport construction;
- The New Galinheiras Municipal
Neighbourhood, built in the 1970s - this initiated the Casal de Nossa
Senhora da Saúde urbanization, developed in two phases (1972/73
- 300 houses and 1976/77 - 207 houses) - for people coming from
degraded accommodation. Today, that kind of urbanisation doesn't exist
and the houses were demolished last year in order to make way for a new
urban project, resulting from a European architecture contest known as
EUROPAN.
- Precarious and illegal buildings.
Meanwhile, a disordered and peripheral
territory has developed, where illegal construction encroaches on the
municipal neighbourhoods. This situation has generated a degraded and
unwelcoming landscape.
The area's image is problematic, featuring low indices of urban
comfort; few collective facilities; few meeting places such as plazas
and squares; almost no cultural, leisure and sporting activities; a
transport system and road network in poorcondition; creating a scenario
with the characteristics to generate spatial fragmentation and social
exclusion.
In addition to some interesting urban
areas, such as the "villas operárias" (housing for people that
works in industrial plants), the space that offers the most potential
for the Galinheiras nucleas is the central square. This is not only
promising on the architectural level but also on the urbanity and urban
experience levels. This square is a focal point, where different axis
crosses, diverse activities go on and people from every age, race and
culture meet together and socialise. And is right here, close to
square, that we find the few existing facilities, exception to the
market.
This square shall constitute the link between the diverse urban
structures and can be the starting point to sustainable urban planning
that unites Galinheiras and the other satellite nuclei around Lisbon
and Loures councils, such as Camarate, Frielas, Odivelas and Loures. We
believe the answer to the majority of Galinheira's urban problems lies
in the development of the square - promoting it, innovating, and
joining it with other squares, creating a network of truly urban plazas
both in- and outside the LUDA case study area, with each plaza related
to an activity or a specific theme, such as music.
Pedro Bento
|
|
|
Migrant workers and illegal buildings
Portugal was a rural country in the
50's. Besides the urban centres of Lisbon and Oporto only some large
villages were known. The urban centres were small areas in a space
managed by a rural population, comprised between two poles: a minority
of manorial families, owners and rich farmers and a large multitude of
rural workers, which lived in bad conditions of life, suffering several
privations. More than ¾ of the population lived in the country
and the national economy depended on it.
Through the 50's and 60's the Portuguese
society, stabilizes optioning by a development relied on the industrial
activity, whose organisation under the ways of capitalist production
and reproduction is mainly concentrated on the western coastal area of
the country, namely in the Lisbon's region. Attracted by low salaries
the external investment is concentrated there, essentially on the
manufacturing industry, creating employment opportunities for the
populations of rural zones, which look for better conditions of life in
the Lisbon's region. The urban structures were not ready for it and,
the suburbs emerge - buildings without any planning as well as
shantytowns starts to come out.
|
|
|
In this context, emerges the problem of the illegal buildings present
in the Lisbon's LUDA area. With the lack of answers planned for new
housing areas and with the inflation of land prices, is in the illegal
self - construction that a part of the housing needs finds answers.
Large areas of urban surroundings with weak probabilities of
urbanisation (weak accessibility, bad topographic or exposure
conditions, or even with urban drawbacks) are illegally divided into
lots. The high construction is a tendency observable in Quinta da
Torrinha and Galinheiras as well as the resource to the excessive
occupation of the blocks, through the construction of small dwellings
and outbuildings for rent.
If in a first phase these houses were
reserved for rural immigrants, the evolution of the city's cycle of
life and the characteristics of the Portuguese society permitted the
arrival of other occupiers. In the beginning of the 70´s and due
to the lack of labour force caused by the emigration (mainly for
France), the State encourages the immigration of workers from Cape
Verde and from other African colonies. As from 1975 there is an
important flux of returnees from the older Portuguese colonies due to
questions of insecurity during the processes of independence of these
territories, which also look for available locals and which, through
rents or illegal self - construction also arrive to the zone of
Galinheiras.
With this flux of immigrants an
important change into the proportion and composition of the immigration
is processed. The foreign population goes from 0,33% in 1960 to 1,10%
in 1981. The most important increasing results from the African
immigration. In 1960 it was composed by 1,5% of foreigners but in 1981
had already reached the 44%.
With the entry of Portugal into the
European Economic Community in 1986, today designated as European
Union, we assist to a radical change into our society: instead of
exporters we are now importers of labour force. Firstly, are the
Africans from Portuguese-speaking countries, which search for work in
the Lisbon's region, followed by other African nationalities. Recently,
there was an increment of immigrants from countries of the European
East (Ukrainians, Moldavians, Romanians, Russians). In April 2002,
there were approximately 389 thousands of immigrants registered in
Portugal and 91 thousands of them were from countries of the European
East. It is estimated that the number of illegal workers is superior to
100 thousands, most of them from Moldavia, Ukraine, Russia and Romania,
and also from countries of Portuguese official language, namely from
Brazil which nowadays represent the highest number of immigrants
arriving to Lisbon.
According to the last census of the
Portuguese population, it was verified that 821 individuals of foreign
nationality resided in the LUDA 's zone, corresponding to 6% of the
total population living in this zone. 65% of these foreigners were from
Portuguese -speaking countries (Angola, Cape Verde, Guinea-Bissau,
São Tomé e Príncipe and Mozambique) and 9% were
Brazilians.
The dwellings of Galinheiras, whose
housing conditions are precarious, are nowadays searched by African
immigrants, most of them illegal ones. With the development of the LUDA
project, the aim is to create the conditions for the restructuring of
these areas now illegal ones, looking for promoting their integration
into a planned concept of urban design in order to permit a regular
functioning of all the urban functions and the necessary change of its
image, removing from it the stigma of illegality.
António Bastos
|
|
|
The Economic Structure of LUDA in
Lisbon
On average, the economic structure of
LUDA area relies on micro enterprises and small businesses dedicated to
activities of insignificant added value and which generate, in general,
less skilled employment.
In the whole area there were less than
400 enterprises/businesses with open door (shops) identified. The most
significant ones are the following:
- 21% coffee houses and restaurants
- 14% decorating, clothing, shoe
shops, hairdressers
- 13,5 garages
- 10% food shops
- 8% storehouses
- 6% technical services
- 3% machine shops
- 2% Graphic arts
If there is any specialization in this
area, it corresponds to the garages where vehicles are repaired; the
remaining activities correspond to commerce of proximity existent in
the whole city.
On the other side, many of the
businesses developed in LUDA are informal ones because concession taxes
for their functioning are not paid and/ or the totality of the taxes
that
shops should be submitted are not also paid (a problem
which is much more national than local).
This characteristic permits to these
activities reduce their prices. Indeed, they will be, temporarily, the
leaders of the market, but this competitiveness will not last in a
long- term. As regards employment, two questions must be referred:
Firstly, the LUDA zone cannot be considered an area for employment
opportunities, neither in terms of quantity nor in terms of quality.
Secondly, as far as concerns the qualifications and conditions of the
residents' work, we verify two very distinct situations:
On one side, the Calçada de
Carriche, Lavadeiras and the historic core of Ameixoeira, in which the
structure of the qualifications is much more superior to the city's
average. In this area commerce and services are relatively developed,
nevertheless in terms of public space there is a lack of a group
intervention, because not only we are speaking of an old population but
also of an old space.
On the other side, in the
Galinheiras/Torrinha area the qualifications level is inferior to the
city's average, the unemployment rate is superior and the traditional
commerce, survives thanks to the low rents and situations of illegality.
Ana Pinheiro Costa
|
|
|
Informal Economy in LUDA
Around 20% of the Portuguese economy is
composed by informal and / or illegal activities, in other words by
parallel economy. This question was the main problem observed in the
justification for the differential of productivity facing the European
average.
There is no doubt that a relative
tolerance facing these activities must be taken into consideration
because many of them can be embryos of micro- enterprises contributing,
in this way, to business-related dynamics so important nowadays, on the
other side, the parallel economy introduces serious distortions in the
competitiveness among economic agents, besides the deviations of the
resources from the public sphere to the private sphere of the economy.
In the LUDA zone the existence of many
illegal economic activities are pointed out, such as the garages, where
vehicles are repaired. This activity does not require, in its essence,
high academic qualifications but a lot of work experience. And if the
"enterprise" does not pay the taxes or the social contribution, and is
located inside the city, it can be an interesting alternative for some
customers. The State must intervene near these situations promoting its
passage for a legal situation. Nevertheless, as is known, an immediate
passage, without a transition period can result into the closing of the
business.
The true is that some of these
businesses will surely close due to the lack of efficiency to operate
in conditions of competitiveness. Nevertheless, other businesses with
economic conditions can be developed because they absorb less skilled
but specialised workers, which would not find immediately work in other
sectors.
In conclusion, when a business has
chances of being developed in competitiveness terms, Lisbon City
Council and the Inland Revenue Department might to develop a programme
in order to support the legalization, namely with a system of
progressive payments supporting the workers' training and/or the
contract of new collaborators with more interesting qualifications for
the enterprise. When there is no conditions for the business succeed,
due to the lack of efficiency, the unemployment will emerge.
The establishing of electromechanical
services of Lisbon City Council in the LUDA area, which is still in
progress, might absorb this unemployment. We should take advantage of
these specialized but less skilled workers, giving preference to the
residents of LUDA.
Ana Pinheiro Costa
|
|
|
Traditional Commerce of Low Rents:
Impact of the new Lease Act
In order to clear up a swampy situation,
which has induced to serious perversions in the economic system, in
particular in the real estate market, a new lease act was proposed.
The freezing of the housing rents and
commerce happened after the World War whose aim was to protect the
leaseholders from inflating processes. This measure was never removed,
which caused, through several decades, an increasing distortion of
prices and conditions. One of the situations, which resulted from this
problem, was the maintaining of the spaces of commerce and services,
stagnated in time, paying very low rents, without any competitive
pressure to be modernised or obtain gains of efficiency. The result it
is visible, owners receiving very low rents, which are not enough to
pay the preservation of these spaces and owners impeded from searching
other leaseholders capable of paying a market rent. On the other hand,
in order to change the "rules of the game" but without changing the
ancient rents, a different legal setting for the rents after 1980 was
introduced in recent years. Thus, today, it is usual to find shops of
very low rents, side by side, with shops of very high rents. This
situation weakens the healthy economic development of businesses due to
an unfair competition.
A new Lease Act was recently proposed,
looking for within 10 years regularise the majority of these situations
and be in line with the market rules. Thus, in a medium- term, an
in-depth change of the economic activity will emerge on the visible
face of that activity - shops, offices, factories, etc. The role of
Lisbon City Council in this changing period will be to identify those
activities, which as part of the city's identity have a public and
strategic interest to maintain, namely through specific supports in the
deficiencies found.
Ana Pinheiro Costa
Informal Real Estate
In the 70's, Portugal was in a
complicated situation with no comparison with other countries, which
resulted in a conjugation of different problems:
- an international crisis
not favourable to Portugal
- a very significant reduction of
the Portuguese emigration, increasing the unemployment in Portugal and
reducing the sending of emigrants
- in a few months 500 thousands of
people returned from the older colonies and an important number of
working people were lost
- a significant rural exodus due to
the lack of opportunities in the interior of the country
- the lack of a stable and right
economic policy in order to face this reality in productive time
The lack of housing supply, not only in
quantity but also in the desired time, led to a very complex result:
thousands of shanties were built in the urban centres; several suburbs
of low quality emerged without any planning, sanitation or facilities;
unemployment increased, finding, afterwards, an answer, in informal
situations or in public employment.
In the sight of this rapid phenomenon
and due to the lack of an economic and structured policy, the State
ended by shutting one's eyes to these situations, "permitting" the
execution of constructions in these conditions, but keeping them in the
illegality. Only later, the legalization problems started, and, today,
there are still many situations to clear up. Illegality separates
owners and leaseholders from the whole system: transaction of real
estates, tax deductions, right to defence in cases of nonfulfilment of
the contract, in conclusion the impossibility of an effective
participation in the city.
The LUDA programme will contemplate a
legalization process of the existing real estates, which guarantee the
minimum of quality and of housing conditions. On the contrary the
demolition will be the only solution. Besides of this selection, a
regulation to change some districts of LUDA, namely at the level of the
facades will be implemented, looking for a coherence in its all.
Ana Pinheiro Costa
|
|
|
A strategy of economic development in
LUDA
The urban competitiveness results from a
set of city's capacities, which permits them to have a specific but
never safeguarded place in the worldwide cities' network. A competitive
city not only is an indicator of performance but mainly a purpose for
improving the quality of life of a population.
Nowadays, we know the urban
competitiveness relies on multiple factors such as the balance of the
urban network where is inserted or the internal and efficient
organisation of the city, in terms of transport networks, services
sophistication or human resources quality, among many other factors.
There is no doubt that is absolutely decisive the existence of a clear
and consensual strategy, of long-term, participated by the citizens and
looking for an innovative direction. Finally, the existence of
disparities, social exclusion, insecurity and the lack of trust, weaken
the urban competitiveness.
These ideas are the basis of the Music
Strategy for LUDA zone. Actually, this is a long-term strategy, which
not only aims a structural transformation, looking for solving the main
problems of the resident people, but also an improvement of the
conditions and quality of life of the whole city. In the heart of the
strategy we have an educational and social project, of empowerment of
the population through the learning of music, being possible to
perceive the multiplier effects that such learning might have on the
other areas of life. In order to this strategy finds its
self-sustainability in time it is necessary to develop activities of
economic characteristic. Therefore, the creation of economic activities
must be carried out - commerce, services, production of instruments,
facilities and accessories of music - in a cluster connected with music.
To carry out this strategy a structure
must be created in order to gather technicians and researchers in the
field of music as well as entrepreneurs with experience in that area
and financial, educational and training institutions. From these
reunion new ideas, new businesses and a complex network activity with a
significant added value must emerge, launching a virtuous process as
regards the creation of new work forces and new enterprises of more
innovative and competitive tendencies.
Ana Pinheiro
Costa
top |
|
hints & upcoming events
|
Next events
|
|
01-03 December 2004
|
Workshop and Public Conference in Salzburg
|
|
20-21 Mai 2005
|
Workshop in Bratislava
|
|
September 2005
|
Workshop and Public Conference in Paris
|
|
|
|
|
disclaimer/
impressum
LUDA Project Team
Project Director: Professor Bernhard Mueller
Leibniz Institute of
Ecological and Regional Development IOER
Weberplatz 1
01217 Dresden (Germany)
fon 0049 351 4679 0
fax 0049 351 4679 212
Editorial staff
Dr. Carlos Smaniotto Costa
Christiane Westphal
Patrycja Bielawska - Roepke
Leander Kuettner
luda-team@ioer.de
www.luda-project.net
We are not responsible for the content of external
web-sites connected with this e-newsletter.
|
|
|
|
|